This page describes an example counselling session designed for clinicians, therapists, doctors, mental health workers, and educators working with individuals struggling with addictions or compulsive behaviours.
In this session, the counsellor uses a whiteboard to show the client a running summary of the counselling session. The counsellor makes a “cobweb diagram” of the client’s words for (1) the pros and cons of an addiction, and (2) other issues in the client’s life. The counsellor then helps the client recognise the destructive vicious cycles driving their presenting problem and later nurtures virtuous recovery cycles.
These interventions are often clinically effective because they can:
- Set a clear goal: disrupting an identified vicious cycle.
- Dispel client fears, e.g., the fear of being crazy.
- Engage clients in the counselling.
- Case study: Client Zed
- The Intake Phone Call
- My Session Plan
- Zed’s Story
- The Cobweb Diagram
- The Respect Intervention
- An Alternative Intervention: Distraction
- An Avoided Intervention: Brain Injury
- Why these cyclic interventions work
- Clinical Follow-up
- Virtuous Cycles of Recovery
- Explaining Vicious Cycles
- Paradoxes and intervention
- Relationship to other therapies
- Related Pages
Case study: Client Zed
This counselling session is with Client Zed, a fictional character based on many clients I saw over ten years as a problem gambling counsellor.
The Intake Phone Call
Zed’s first contact with our problem gambling counselling service was through an intake phone worker who arranged a face-to-face appointment with me. The intake notes recorded:
- Client: 29 years old. Living with his mother.
- Presenting Issues: Horse-racing gambling debts, recent job loss, pending criminal court appearance.
- Referral Source: His lawyer suggested that attending counselling could help him in court.
- Note: When offered our normal information sheets, he said, “No. Don’t bother. I don’t remember things.”
My Session Plan
Zed said he had difficulty remembering, so I planned to keep the session structured and simple. I frequently used a whiteboard to provide clients with a visible, running summary of the session layout, set out as a cobweb diagram of: (1) what he liked about gambling, (2) what he disliked, and (3) other critical life events.
Zed’s Story
Here is Zed’s story chronologically.
- School & Work: Bullied heavily by peers, Zed came to hate school and dropped out in Year 11 at age 16. After various labouring jobs, he worked at a local supermarket for five years.
- Relationship Betrayal: At 23, he was renting a small bungalow and met a woman who moved in with him. He thought it was going well, but after one year, she moved out abruptly when he discovered she had been secretly taking money from his bank account to play on poker machines.
- Football Comradeship: At twenty-four, he started playing with a local football team, and football helped him recover from the breakup. He had a light frame for football, but made up for it with speed, and he never gave up. He loved going to the pub with teammates and betting.
- Car accident: At twenty-seven, a serious car accident hospitalised him for two months. He had to give up his bungalow, and on leaving the hospital, he moved into his mother’s rented house.
- Losing Football: When he returned to football training, he couldn’t regain his fitness and agility. Frustrated and quick-tempered, he argued with selectors, stormed out, and never returned.
- Escalating Gambling: A year later, still living with his mother, his horse betting escalated. He often gambled away rent and food money, which triggered arguments with his mother. When his mother called him “crazy,” he half-accepted it (“I suppose I am a bit crazy”). He rejected her suggestion to see a doctor about his memory and head injury. (“I told her to stop thinking about that.”).
- Watching TV: He was often broke and stuck at home, watching professional football on television. He admired the captain of the team he followed (“He’s so brave. Everyone looks up to him.”)
- The Appeal of Gambling: Whenever Zed mentioned gambling, his voice lifted, and his face brightened. He loved betting. On winning days, he felt invincible: people congratulated him, asked for tips, bought him drinks, and he got chatting to women. For a few hours, he shed his identity as a supermarket worker (“It’s a pathetic job.”) and felt like a professional gambler.
- Stealing and Court: When his debts mounted, he began stealing from work. His bosses found out, and he lost his long-standing job. Now, facing court, he worried it would make the news.
- At 29, he felt alone and weighed down by a string of defeats.
The Cobweb Diagram
For much of our session, I stood at the whiteboard adding to a cobweb diagram as we spoke, mostly using Zed’s words. I set out the diagram as follows:
Here is the cobweb diagram as it appeared at the end of the session, including the vicious cycle intervention in red that I am about to explain.

The Respect Intervention
Zed was talking regretfully about losing his football mates. I’d intended to keep the session very simple, but I saw a vicious cycle around “respect” in his story and decided to move towards using it as an intervention.
Me: You miss the respect you got from those football mates, and you really respect the captain of the football team you follow. You seem to be longing for respect.
He nodded, saying, “Yeh, too right.”, so I added the “need respect” to the diagram.
I pointed to parts of the diagram as we talked, and I covered the following ground:
Me: You’ve said that when you are on a winning streak, you feel you can’t lose, people ask you for tips and buy you drinks, and you get chatting to women. You feel respected. (I added the red “feel respected” to the diagram.) …. However, you’ve often lost money and then lost respect at home, and now at work, too. (I added the red “lose respect” to the diagram.) …. Then, just like on the football field, you don’t give up. You return to the horses, hoping for your next winning streak and to feel respected once again.
I summarised, saying, “There seems to be a cycle at work here: (1) The more you gamble to feel respected during your winning streaks, (2) the more money you lose and the less respect you receive at home and work. (3) This increases your need for respect, which (4) throws you right back into gambling to feel respected again. This vicious cycle could be driving your gambling.”
Zed’s Response
Zed stared at the whiteboard, stood up, and pointed to the playing card symbols embossed on his wide belt.
He said, “That’s what’s on my belt. A friend made it for me with these diamonds and clubs. I picked diamonds for betting, and clubs for respect. They go together. But you’re saying more than that: betting breaks respect, and, well, … I suppose that’s right. No one put it that way before.”
Later, he said, “Mum says I’m crazy, but maybe that’s not it.”
I asked him to name the vicious cycle, and he came up with “Respect Twister”. This made it easier to refer to this cycle later.
This session was an exception.
In this counselling session, I hit the jackpot by landing on “respect”, a word so relevant to Zed that he had a symbol for it on his belt. This was not a typical session. Zed’s response to the intervention amazed me and fueled my enthusiasm for working this way.
An Alternative Intervention: Distraction
I often used a cycle that could apply to many people, for example, identifying how people (1) use gambling to distract themselves from stressors, but (2) lose money, which tends to (3) compound those stressors.
To have used this “distraction intervention” with Client Zed, I would have inserted (1) stresses, (2) gambling for distraction, and (3) damage into the cobweb diagram, as I discussed this with him, saying things like:
You’ve had a stressful time with your girlfriend’s betrayal, the car accident injury, lost fitness, losing football, losing your bungalow, and needing to move back in with your mother. I’ve seen many sportsmen, after injury, slip into gambling to distract themselves from losing their sport. The trouble is that your gambling has piled on more stress: losing money, debt, crime, losing your job, and court. There’s a cycle here: (1) stress, (2) gambling to distract yourself from the stress and (3) gambling damage, which adds to the stress.
An Avoided Intervention: Brain Injury
I chose not to use one intervention that occurred to me during the session because I thought it could alienate Zed.
Zed said his mother suggested he see a doctor about his memory, and I could see he strongly opposed it. This suggested the following cycle.
In this possible cycle:
- Zed feared that something was wrong with his mind.
- To counter that fear, he gambled more, chasing winning streaks and the feeling of being a smart professional gambler with a good head on his shoulders.
- This gambling led to more damage: more lost money and occasions when his mother told him he was “crazy” and needed to see a doctor.
- These consequences reinforced his fear that something was wrong with his head, and then the cycle repeats.
The strength of his opposition to seeing a doctor about his injury suggested that he could resist this as an explanation of his gambling. Nevertheless, it could have been one vicious cycle driving his gambling.
Why these cyclic interventions work
Here are some reasons why these cyclic interventions work.
They offer reassurance
These interventions can reassure clients by offering a non-pathologising understanding of their problem. After the intervention, Zed questioned whether his mother was right about him being crazy. He was now thinking there was another reason for his gambling: the vicious cycle.
The intervention also presented Zed’s gambling as a misguided pursuit of a reasonable human need: gaining respect.
Clients understand the cycle diagram.
Clients understand these vicious cycles presented as a diagram within the cobweb diagram. The diagram doesn’t overload clients and makes systems theory’s cyclic logic easy to grasp, even for clients with poor memory or heightened emotions.
Enhanced reflective listening
The vicious cycle emerged from the cobweb diagram in front of us, with each part supported by words Zed used to tell his story. This process enhanced reflective listening by reflecting the entire session.
Increased engagement
Clients consistently found these cyclic interventions lifted a weight off their shoulders and increased engagement in counselling. This certainly applied to Client Zed.
Simple process
The process of making a cobweb diagram of the pros and cons of gambling on a whiteboard, along with the underlying “other issues,” is simple and deliberately structured to produce a vicious cycle around a need or dread. The counsellor can choose to use it or not.
Clinical Follow-up
For Client Zed, the clinical follow-up included:
- Working out how to disrupt the vicious cycle:
- Limiting his gambling
- Reducing the gambling damage (harm reduction)
- Understanding his need for respect
- Developing Zed’s narratives around his strengths and solutions
- Identifying virtuous cycles that supported his recovery
Virtuous Cycles of Recovery
Zed had responded well to the reframing of his gambling problem as a vicious cycle, but, by itself, this has the potential to be demoralising. I aimed to encourage him by explicitly presenting his strengths and moves against his gambling as virtuous, self-reinforcing cycles of recovery. See the virtuous cycles of recovery page.
Explaining Vicious Cycles
I now raise a completely different situation because I often use it to explain how a vicious cycle can develop in a relationship.
Many of my clients were women taking time out at the pokies and getting into trouble with their gambling. A possible cycle here is that they:
- Experience problems in their marriage,
- Escape to a gambling venue (the pokies) for a safe, peaceful time out and distraction, leading to
- Greater money losses, which
- Increase problems in the marriage, which leads to more gambling.
A vicious cycle like this tends to escalate (1) the gambling, (2) the gambling losses, and (3) the relationship problems
Paradoxes and intervention
You can view each intervention I discussed here as a paradox.
- Respect: Zed gambled to feel respect while winning, but it lost him respect.
- Stress: He gambled to distract himself from stress, but it increased it.
- Sanity: He could have been using gambling to convince people that his brain was not damaged, but it made people think he was crazy.
The cyclic diagrams are a useful way to clarify these paradoxes and others. I explore paradoxes on the linked page.
Relationship to other therapies
On separate pages, I argue that these cyclic interventions are related to other therapies and theories.
Systems Theory
Feedback cycles lie at the heart of systems theory. See my page on the Systems Theory underlying this understanding of human behaviour based on feedback cycles.
Psychodynamic therapy
When a human experiences (1) “mental pain”, they can adopt (2) a “defence” to avoid this pain. This can lead to (3) “damaging consequences” and set up a vicious circle. (Malan, 1979). The Respect Twister is a vicious cycle following this pattern: Zed’s (1) need for respect led to (2) gambling, which led to (3) damaging consequences. See my page on psychodynamic therapy.
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy
The intervention effectively challenged Zed’s powerful belief that gambling was an effective way of gaining respect. This is a cognitive intervention challenging an unhelpful thought. See my page on cognitive behavioural therapy.
Weinberg’s Therapy
George Weinberg’s ideas informed this cyclic intervention. Weinberg worked with clients to identify the dread that drove their compulsive habits. See my page on Weinberg’s Therapy.
Narrative therapy
The intervention framed Zed’s problem gambling as an external entity, so I could use narrative therapy questioning to explore Zed’s relationship with the entity, its methods of deception, and its culture. See my page on Narrative therapy.
Rogerian Client-Centred Therapy
Understanding problem gambling as a vicious cycle and using this as a counselling intervention helped me to provide counselling more consistent with the principles of Rogerian counselling. See my page on Rogerian therapy and the cyclic intervention.
Related Pages
The Process of Developing this Framework: This Framework evolved over ten years of counselling in a problem gambling service, alongside academic study of my counselling practice and conference presentations.
Loaded 16 Nov 2025. Updated 11 Nov 2026.