Using Vicious & Virtuous Cycles in Counselling

**** Page under editing 18 Nov 2026

Systems theory offers a practical way to explain problem gambling to clients, not as a moral failing, but as a set of self-reinforcing feedback loops: vicious cycles that drive problems, and virtuous cycles that drive recovery.

I illustrate this by presenting several extracts from counselling sessions with a problem gambler, but the concepts are equally relevant to many other client problems.

Each extract offers language that a counsellor could use when a client reports an instance when they:

  • Satisfy a key need in a constructive way
  • Cannot stop thoughts luring then to their problem behaviour
  • Turn away from their problem behaviour
  • Take on constructive activities
  • Want to develop an aspect of themselves, like become more generous

Clients readily understand vicious cycle diagrams. That part is straightforward, but introducing virtuous cycles requires the counsellor to present some concepts to the client. I tried to do this education as a collaborative dialogue. Having introduced the concept of a self-reinforcing recovery cycle, I can:

  • Highlight how the client’s movements towards recovery are strengthening a self-reinforcing recovery cycle.
  • Focus on a client strength and affirm their movement towards recovery,
  • Provide a psychological framework explaining why their efforts support their recovery
  • Discuss how the client might nurture this recovery cycle
  • Build self-efficacy
  • Provide realistic hope in the face of the vicious cycles driving their problem
  • Easily use these concepts again in future sessions.

This is consistent with motivational interviewing (Miller and Rollnick, 1991)


1.2        On this page

1.3        The dread, defence, damage cycle

I have presented the key vicious cycle driving Client Zed’s problem gambling on a separate page which also covers (1) how the vicious cycle emerged in the counselling session, and (2) this intervention’s relationship with other forms of therapy. In brief:

***

In my first counselling session with Client Zed, I wrote his words on a whiteboard under three headings: (1) What he liked about gambling, (2) What he disliked, and (3) Other issues in his life. I saw a cycle linking what he had said, and discussed this with him:

Diagram: Vicious cycle: Need for respect à gamble to experience the winning streaks and fleeting respect from others à lost money and respect à greater need for respect. (ZC01N3)

I formed this cycle by linking elements of his story, drawing arrows within the whiteboard diagram, and summed up saying, “There seems to be a cycle at work here: (1) The more you gamble to feel respected during your winning streaks, (2) the more money you lose and the less respect you receive at home and work. (3) This increases your need for respect, which (4) throws you back into gambling to feel respected. This vicious cycle could be driving your gambling.”

Seeing this vicious cycle was a revelation for Zed. He realised that his strategy for gaining respect was actively destroying it. When I asked him to name the cycle, he called it the respect twister. (Zed is a composite client based on numerous real clients.)

The example counselling session page details this session.

1.3.1       Recovery cycles around respect

In our third session, Zed said: “I’ve been to a couple of Gamblers Anonymous (GA) meetings. …. One bloke there said my story helped him … a woman said that too.”

I drew this as a cycle on the whiteboard.

***** Diagram: (ZC17N3S) In this feedback cycle:

  • Action: Go to GA meetings
  • Reward: People say your words helped them.
  • Motivation to go to GA increases
  • Action: Return to GA and the cycle repeats.

I pointed to the diagram as I spoke: “(1) You go to GA, and (2) others tell you that what you said helped them and that feels good, (3) your motivation to go back increases, and you tend to (4) go back to GA and (5) the cycle can repeat.”

Me: “This is a self-reinforcing cycle supporting your recovery. The more you go, the more you can feel valued and move away from gambling.”

When I asked if he felt those people also respected him, he paused, saying it was “sort of right.” We talked about the grounded, earned respect at GA and the fleeting, respect he chased at the racetrack.

Me: “You’ve set up a self-reinforcing cycle that can help you move away from gambling. Valuing and nurturing this cycles will help you, especially when you gain a sort of respect from this cycle.”

(See the Rewards page for more on how rewards reinforce an activity.)

1.4        Denial: The Gambling Shock Denial Cycle

In our fourth session, Zed said, “Sometimes when I think about it, I can barely believe I ended up telling so many lies. Mum says I’m not myself anymore.”

Me: “You are shocked at yourself.”

I put a poster of the following generic cycle on the whteboard.

*** Cycle Diagram: The denial cycle: Could use this. here.

Gambling à shocking damage à pause then deny the shocks à more gambling

Me: “(1) You’ve gambled and (2) ended up shocking yourself. Today your past lies are shocking you. These shocks will have (3) paused your betting, but after a while you learn to deny the shock and (4) then you’ve gone back to betting.”

Me: “Each turn of this cycle increases your gambling, the severity of the shocks, and your ability to deny the shocks, your self-tricking thinking.”

Me: “What are some other gambling shocks you have experienced?”

We talked about times when he lost fifty dollars for the first time, lost his whole wage, started borrowing, and more.

Me: “You’ve shocked yourself many times and denied those shocks to continue gambling. It seems that this cycle, with its growing denial, has changed your character and had you telling lies a lot, so much that today you and your mum can barely believe it”

Me: “Today as you recall these shocks you can learn from them, unwind your self-tricking thinking, and weaken this denial cycle”

See my page on denial and addiction

1.5        The singular focus of a compulsive habit

In our fifth session, Zed said, “Sometimes I just think about gambling for hours. It’s nuts.”

Me: “I’ve got a way to explain how gamblers become so obsessed by gambling. It’s based on books written by a therapist George Weinberg. This could be too much like a school lesson. Let me know if it’s not working for you.”

[See my page on Weinberg’s therapy for fuller details]

1.5.1       Obsession & Chosen Activity Cycles

Me: “Whenever you choose to gamble, you strengthen each of your ideas and feelings that motivate you to gamble. This is separate from the changes in motivation due to winning or losing.”

Me: “What’s one idea that attracted you to gambling? … What’s one feeling that got you gambling?”

Zed: “The big idea is on my belt: gambling brings respect. … One feeling. Oh yes, the excitement of winning and people gathering around.”

Me: “Each time you placed a bet, you strengthened each of these motivations and others, forming a vicious cycle.”

I put up a poster of the following generic feedback cycle on the whiteboard.

Cycle Diagram

ZCW01N2

[Perform a chosen activity] à [Strengthen each idea and feeling motivating the activity] à [Perform the activity more]

Me: “This cycle happens for gambling – or any chosen activity: (1) your gambling tends to (2) strengthen each idea and feeling motivating your gambling, and then (3) you tend to gamble again and (4) the cycle repeats.”

Me: “A common saying provides an example. “When you fall off your horse, get back on.”. That advice is rooted in concern about (1) the action of refusing to get back on, (2) increasing the motivating feeling of fear about falling, causing (3) further refusal to mount, and (4) the cycle repeating. Does this make sense to you?” …

Me: “You’ve gambled lots over recent years and each bet tends to strengthen your gambling motivations. I’m saying that this will be one reason that you can think about gambling for hours.”

Me: “There is another reason too. Will I go on?”

1.5.2       Obsession & Rejected Activity Motivation Cycles

Me: “Each time you gamble you reject alterative activities and reduce your motivation to do these alternatives.

I put up a poster of the following generic feedback cycle on the whiteboard.

Diagram ZCW02N2

[Rejected activities] à [decreases your ideas and feelings motivating these alternatives] à [more rejection of these alternatives]

Me: “(1) Each time you bet you reject all the other things you could have been doing and (2) weaken each idea and feeling motivating these activities, so you tend to (3) bet again, and (5) the cycle repeats. The motivation for all the rejected activities grows smaller and smaller. After years of gambling you can have little motivation for anything except gambling.

Me: “This is another self-reinforcing cycle: the rejected activity motivation cycle.”

1.6        Four cycles driving your gambling

Me: “So, you’ve got four separate cycles driving your gambling:

  • The respect twister pushing you to gamble to get that respect
  • The denial cycle building your ability to brush off gambling shocks
  • The chosen activity cycle has lots of gambling pushing your motivation to gamble sky-high.
  • The rejected activity cycle, has lots of gambling killing off your motivations to do non-gambling activities.”

Me: “After gambling for a long time, you have become highly motivated to gamble and barely interested in anything else. You come to think that gambling is right and necessary.”

Me: “It’s no wonder that you still think about gambling for hours at a time.”

1.7        The client takes a step towards recovery

Later in this fifth session, Zed talked about a step towards recovery.

Zed: “Like I said, last week, I was hanging out to go to the track. … I had $50 and got on the train to go to the races – but I got off next stop and walked home. … On my way I bought some screws, and then fixed mum’s chair. … I thought mum would get a surprise when her chair didn’t jiggle. She did.”

1.7.1       Recovery: Rejecting problem behaviour

Me: “Your getting off the train tells me that you are starting up some self-reinforcing cycles that are supporting your recovery. I can describe them briefly. Are you up for it?”

Me: “When you got off the train you rejected gambling.”

I pointed to the poster I put on the whiteboard earlier.

ZCW02N2

Diagram: Reject an activity à decreases each idea and feeling motivating that activity à make it easier to reject the activity again.

Me: “When you got off the train, (1) you rejected gambling, which tends to (2) weaken each thing that attracts you to gambling, which tends to (3) reduce the chances that you’ll gamble again.”

Me: “Every race day when you think of betting and don’t, you reject gambling again, further weaken your gambling motivation, and supporting your recovery.”

Me: “The rejected activity cycle supports your recovery when you reject gambling.”

1.7.2       Recovery: Increasing Constructive activities

Me: “When you bought those screws and fixed your mum’s chair, you activated another recovery cycle. What motivated you to fix the chair?

Zed: “To do something around the house. … To get back into being a handyman. …. To help mum.”

I pointed to the following poster I had put on the whiteboard earlier.

Cycle Diagram

ZCW01N2

[A chosen action] à [motivations supporting the action] à [the chosen action]

Me: “When you fixed that chair, you activated recovery cycles for all your motivations, including those you have mentioned. One recovery cycle is (1) your motivation to be more of a handyman led to (2) you fixing the chair, which tends to (3) strengthen your motivation to be a handyman, which tends to (4) repeat the cycle.

Me: “The chosen activity cycle supports your recovery when you chose constructive activities.

Me: “How might you strengthen these recovery cycles? Would you think of going to the Salvos and getting another chair to fix, or something like that?”

1.8        The client wants a specific change

In our eighth session, Zed said, “I’ve been so mean to mum. I’d like to be more generous to her, and others.”

Me: “Here’s a way you can work on that. Whenever you feel a flutter of generosity in yourself, act on it. Tell me about a recent time you’ve felt a little generous.”

Zed: “Mum bought me in cup of tea while I watched TV. I said thanks. She tries to look after me.”

I pointed to the chosen activity cycle diagram already on the whiteboard.

Diagram: Chosen activity à motivation à activity

Me: “Motivation: You felt thankful. And you acted, you said thanks. You’ve started a self-reinforcing cycle of being thankful which is a form of generosity. What could you do to keep this going, to make your thankfulness and generosity more obvious?

We talked about other ways he could do this. Zed said he say “thanks for looking after me” or buy her flowers. At one point I noted a danger.

Me: “Some people have this wrong. They advise people to act in a generous way to become more generous. However, that only works if a feeling of generosity motivates your action. If you acted and bought everyone in your street flowers, motivated by feeling like a mean person and trying to prove otherwise, that would leave you feeling more mean or even deceptive That is not how you become more generous.”

Me: “If you want to become more generous, act on those flutters of real generosity within yourself and this generosity can grow. How else could you do this?”

*HERE checking the Gemini version. Up to here

1.9        Relapse & Recovery

Me: “Initially your self-reinforcing recovery cycles are like babies, they have potential but are weak. With nurturing they can grow rapidly, but they oppose established cycles driving your gambling. Gambling lures you with offering high excitement and a respect. It’s easy to relapse.

Me: “You had a close shave the day you got off the train to the racetrack, what strengths helped you get off the train? “

Me: “How can you can strengthen these recovery cycles? Would you think of going to the Salvos and getting another chair to fix or something like that?”

1.10    Conclusion

This page has explicitly shown how a counsellor can use the amplifying feedback cycles of systems theory in counselling sessions: the vicious cycles of problem development and the virtuous cycles of recovery.

The counselling extracts provide the sort of succinct language that a counsellor can use when the client reports an instant in which when they:

  • Constructively meet a need that drives their gambling
  • Report obsessive thinking about their problem behaviour
  • Turn away from their problem behaviour
  • Take up constructive activities
  • Express a desire for personal growth, e.g., to become more generous

Highlighting the virtuous cycles formed when a client takes a step towards recovery, such as going home to fix a chair rather than heading to the races, shows the client that recovery is not just about stopping a harmful habit. Instead, it’s also about actively nurturing self-reinforcing cycles that draw them toward a broader, more rewarding life.

1.11    End of rewritten page

******* old

Supporting recovery

The counselling session with client Zed focuses on the client’s presenting problem. It’s problem-focused therapy. Clients often welcome the identification of the vicious gambling cycle, but the counsellor also needs to provide balance by focusing on client strengths and solutions. Narrative therapy is one way of doing this. Another dimension is focusing on the virtuous cycles apparent in the client’s past and as therapy sessions continue.


Recovery for Client Zed

For Client Zed, an element of recovery could have been going to Gamblers Anonymous (GA) meetings, offering grounded support to other participants based on his own experience, earning their respect, and so reducing his need to gain respect via gambling. Going to GA meetings would establish three recovery cycles that would counter the dominance of his gambling-amplifying cycle.


The reward of gaining respect

First is the cycle around gaining respect from other GA members.

Diagram: This feedback cycle amplifies client Zed’s (1) giving assistance, (2) gaining respect, and (3) his motivation to assist.
Diagram: This feedback cycle amplifies client Zed’s (1) giving assistance, (2) gaining respect, and (3) his motivation to assist.(ZC17N3S)

In this feedback cycle:

  • Zed’s increased assistance to others tends to
  • Increase the respect he gains from those he helped, which tends to
  • Increase his motivation to assist others, which tends to
  • Increase his assistance to others, and then the cycle repeats.

After identifying a vicious gambling cycle, it is helpful to identify an activity that deals in some way with the dread that drives their problem and explain to the client how dealing with the dread can create a virtuous, self-reinforcing cycle of recovery.

See the Rewards page.


His attendance reinforces his motivations to attend

Second, his attendance at GA meetings directly reinforces each of his motivations to attend.

Diagram: This feedback cycle amplifies Zed’s (1) giving assistance, (2) gaining respect, and (3) his motivation to assist.
Diagram: This feedback cycle amplifies Zed’s (1) giving assistance, (2) gaining respect, and (3) his motivation to assist. (ZC16N2S)

See my page on Weinberg’s Therapy.


His rejection of gambling in favour of GA

Third, there is the cycle which decreases his motivation to go gambling due to his rejection of gambling in favour of attending GA.

Diagram: The feedback cycle amplifying the rejection of (1) gambling and (2) its motivations.
Diagram: The feedback cycle amplifying the rejection of (1) gambling and (2) its motivations. (ZC22N2Sa)

Again, see my page on Weinberg’s Therapy.


These virtuous amplifying feedback cycles could have supported Zed’s recovery.


Three types of recovery cycles

Similar cycles to those that organise problem development can also organise recovery from a problem behaviour:

  • Cycles based on the rewards from recovery activities.
  • Cycles amplifying the choice of recovery activities
  • Cycles amplifying the rejection of the problematic behaviour in favour of recovery activities

Hope

Learning that a vicious problem cycle is dominating your life can be frightening. Understanding that you can strengthen virtuous recovery cycles can counter this fear by identifying achievements and generating hope that an escape route exists.


Links to the three Hub Pages are in the footer below and in the menu above.


Loaded 22 Sep 2206

No featured image. Try PNG of ZC17N3S